fesco

#1846 F28 approved Changes not in MODIFIED status (considered as not testable)
Closed Opened by jkurik.

Closed
Reopen Issue

Hi FESCo,

on 2018-Feb-20 we have reached Fedora 28 Change Checkpoint: Completion deadline (testable). At this point, all accepted changes should be substantially complete, and testable. Change tracking bugs should be set to MODIFIED state to indicate it achieved completeness.

The following link is a dynamic Bugzilla query showing all the tracking bugs of approved Changes for F28 which are not at least in MODIFIED state: Not testable Changes.

On Friday on 2018-Feb-23, before the FESCo meeting, I will do review all of these Changes and I will update this ticket with static list of Changes needing FESCo review.

This is the static list of Change Proposals which are not reported as "testable":

Atomic, Cloud and Container images for s390x

  • Tracking bug: #1547235
  • Status: Mostly done, needs approx. a week to finish it. See this comment
  • Change owner: @sinnykumari

Strong crypto settings

  • Tracking bug: #1534532
  • Status: No response from the Change owner
  • Change owner: @nmav

Thunderbolt Enablement

  • Tracking bug: #1534594
  • Status: No response from the Change owner
  • Change owner: @gicmo

Avoid /usr/bin/python in RPM build

  • Tracking bug: #1537244
  • Status: Change owners are proposing to postpone to the next release. See the owner's comment.
  • Change owner: @churchyard , @pviktori

Anaconda modularization

Glibc collation update and sync with cldr

  • Tracking bug: #1537247
  • Status: No response from the Change owner
  • Change owner: @mfabian

Kerberos in Python modernization

  • Tracking bug: #1537249
  • Status: Unknown
  • Change owner: @rharwood

mpfr-4.0.0

  • Tracking bug: #1537252
  • Status: Change owners are proposing to postpone this to the next release. See this coment.
  • Change owner: @jamesturner246

Add-On Modularity

  • Tracking bug: #1537253
  • Status: No response from the Change owner
  • Change owner: @sgallagh , @langdon

OpenLDAP without Non-threaded Libraries

  • Tracking bug: #1537260
  • Status: Change owner is proposing to postpone this to the next release. See this comment.
  • Change owner: @mhonek
Edited by jkurik

AGREED: changes wishing to defer to f29 can do so now, the rest we revisit next week for response or testable. (+5,0,0)

The following Changes were deferred on request of Change owner(s):

~~Avoid /usr/bin/python in RPM build~~

  • Tracking bug: #1537244
  • Status: Change owners are proposing to postpone to the next release. See the owner's comment.
  • Change owner: @churchyard , @pviktori

~~mpfr-4.0.0~~

  • Tracking bug: #1537252
  • Status: Change owners are proposing to postpone this to the next release. See this coment.
  • Change owner: @jamesturner246

~~OpenLDAP without Non-threaded Libraries~~

  • Tracking bug: #1537260
  • Status: Change owner is proposing to postpone this to the next release. See this comment.
  • Change owner: @mhonek

@jkurik any updates here?

@jkurik any updates here?

I typically update the ticket a few hours before the FESCo meeting to provide FESCo with the latest possible status. I am planning to refresh the list approx. at Friday's noon [CET].

This is the static list of Change Proposals which are not reported as "testable" (updated on 2018-Mar-02 @ 11:30UTC):

Atomic, Cloud and Container images for s390x

  • Tracking bug: #1547235
  • Status: Mostly done, but still needs some time to finish it. See this comment
  • Change owner: @sinnykumari

Thunderbolt Enablement

  • Tracking bug: #1534594
  • Status: Still needs some time (approx. a week) to finish it. See this comment.
  • Change owner: @gicmo

Glibc collation update and sync with cldr

Add-On Modularity

  • Tracking bug: #1537253
  • Status: No response from the Change owner
  • Change owner: @sgallagh , @langdon
Edited by jkurik

I will try to attend today's FESCo meeting, but if I'm not able to attend, please consider me as +1 to giving s390x, thunderbolt, and glibc features another week to fully bake. I'm sitting right next to @langdon right now, and I'd like to get a bit of feedback before make a formal vote on the "Add-On Modularity" feature.

+1 to giving s390x, thunderbolt, and glibc features another week to fully bake

AGREED: FESCo will wait another week for the changes not in MODIFIED status (+6, 0, -0)

As we are already in Beta freeze for F28 release, I believe we can close this ticket and focus on F28 Changes not in ON_QA status (<100% completed).

Yeah, let's move the discussion to the new ticket.

Metadata Update from @zbyszek:
- Issue untagged with: meeting
- Issue status updated to: Closed (was: Open)
Metadata
None
None
None
None
None
Static archive. pagure.io was sunset in 2026; this is a read-only snapshot.
Red Hat Logo

Fedora is sponsored by Red Hat. Learn more about the relationship between Red Hat and Fedora »

© Red Hat, Inc. and others.