No other packages outside the gedit ecosystem currently depends on these libraries. (Full disclosure: I have proposed the addition of enter-tex in https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=2427068 which would, but that originates from the same project and therefore stays in sync.) Therefore, for all practical purposes, this would be self-contained, but as it strictly speaking would again be an incompatible change, pursuant to https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/fesco/Updates_Policy/#_exceptions I am hereby requesting an exception to bring this back to F44 following final freeze. Users would benefit from the latest changes, and it simplifies maintenance for me by having to deal with fewer versions (since, unlike GNOME proper, only the latest version is supported).
Furthermore, as this appears to be an issue that will keep arising, I am further requesting that this exception become permanent, in order to avoid future such requests. In essence, even though the libgedit-* packages provide libraries, as they are practically only dependencies of program(s) from the same project which is following its own schedule, I would like to be able to update them as if they were part of gedit itself.
A COPR is available for testing: https://copr.fedorainfracloud.org/coprs/yselkowitz/gedit-latest/
+1 for this exception and the permanent one.
+1 for this exception but -1 for a permanent one. Technically I really don't think this exception is needed unless this is post-GA for F44.
As a general rule, gedit should be upgraded alongside the rest of the GNOME stack.
Upstream is not following GNOME's schedule anymore.
I'm +1 for the gedit 50 for GNOME 50 exception, but -1 for a permanent one. If the release numbers just accidentally line up right now because gedit is no longer following the GNOME release schedule, then they will just naturally misalign in the future, and that's OK.
Agreed, +1 for this time but -1 for a permanent one. Upstream not following GNOME's schedule means we really should examine each case carefully for now. Also
This was discussed and voted on during today's meeting (logs):
AGREED: The one-time Updates Policy exception to ship gedit 50 for Fedora 44 is approved. A permanent exception is not granted, since it is unclear how the release cycles of gedit, GNOME, and Fedora will align in the future. (+6, 0, -0) (@decathorpe:fedora.im, 17:20:31)
Announced: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@lists.fedoraproject.org/thread/P5FFJJXC5WMQN3LYLAHEINC5XSYZCOZD/
Metadata Update from @decathorpe: - Issue close_status updated to: Accepted - Issue status updated to: Closed (was: Open)